Who is Farhan Lalji? Rotating Header Image

Places to live

So Monocle released it’s most liveable cities list for this year (the list is behind a wall although there is a video recap, this site has the top line list). I keep trying to write about it and keep erasing my entire post. Let’s try one more time.

I hate this list.

I think everyone has different criteria for what makes a place liveable and most of the cities in the Monocle list would not make my short list. My criteria would include:

Don’t smoke in my face. Any city that doesn’t have a ban on smoking in public enclosed places would automatically fall off my list.

Be tolerant almost to a fault. Any city that doesn’t allow/recognize gay relationships wouldn’t make my short list. Not just because I think all people should be allowed to be happy and have equal rights. Also because as Richard Florida‘s research has shown, wealth follows the pink crowd – I’m paraphrasing, but the point is basically that.

For the most part be courteous – I would take a stroller with a child or my 8 month pregnant wife around the city and see if anyone offers her/us a seat.

Solid public transport – I want to be able to get to work, entertainment and the airport all without needing a car or a cab, easily.

Other people – I love knowing that the city has produced great thinkers, great artists, and attracts other people with big ideas. Being attractive to other migrants and having a history of big thinkers is important to me.

Traveling to other places – I want to live in a city where adventure is a short hop away. Whether it’s in Asia, Africa, Europe, Latin or North America, knowing that I can experience different cultures within a couple of hours (max 4).

Think six criteria is enough of a start, the list will probably change when we have kids, but for right now that’s my list. There’s other important stuff as well, like can family travel there easily, can we travel back to our family easily, but these are deal breakers. What are your criteria for where you live or want to live?

Share
  • Adrian Short

    If you look at the magazine you’ll find that many of Monocle’s criteria are the same as your own. They include international air connections, qualitative assessments of public transport and tolerance, ease of starting a business and the murder and burglary rate.

    What all these things come back to is the fundamental promise and challenge of the city: to enable people to resolve their most basic conflicts. We have a need for individuality and community membership. Solitude and sociability. Work and play. To be connected to a place but not bound to it. It’s a hard balancing act to pull off but I believe that mass urban living is the only serious prospect for sustainable and happy human habitation on this planet. It’s good for Monocle (among many others) to bring these issues to the fore and encourage more people to join the debate and the action on how to make our cities great places to live.

    What are your favourite cities?

  • Natasja

    Kudos to Monocle for having a stab at it, though I don’t agree with their list I have to say.

    For all the things I like to see in my favourite cities (good public transport, great museums, great music venues, good food both of the restaurant and the shop variety, great bookstores, good parks, good connections to other places), there’s also that undefinable quality that makes a great city a great city to live in. That thing that is hard to quantify, even harder to describe. Something in the air, an energy. Which means that Zurich probably doesn’t top my list, but London scores high. Why Barcelona for me doesn’t do it, but Madrid does.

    Oh, and also, there has to be something that you trade off. No city is perfect. And I reckon it’s hard to love something which is absolutely perfect. You have to have something that’s less good to make you fall in love!

  • Farhan Lalji

    Great comment Adrian. My thinking on this is that we all have different targets on the spectrum between each of the conflicts you’ve pointed out, so for anyone to say these are the most liveable cities, misses that element.

    I take special conflict with the fact that the Monocle writers write from the perspective of visitors, they all basically live in London!

    Look at who lives there, how happy they are, why they choose to live in those cities.

    My list is pretty short, I love London and Paris, would like to give New York and San Francisco a try. Would also try Sydney and Hong Kong as well. But that’s my list. What’s yours?

  • Farhan Lalji

    Bookstores and parks are on my list as well! Shared green space ranks high on my list, it’s just not a deal breaker.

    You’re right no city is perfect, that was what I was trying to communicate. A city might be perfect for one person but totally wrong for another. Everyone needs to find their own perfect city!

  • http://www.fiftybyfifty.com/lifeoffarhan/2009/07/26/going_places/ Going places – Who is Farhan Lalji?

    [...] the great things abt them for u?” for his blog. It’s a topic I’ve thought about, I wrote a bit of a critical post about Monocle magazine’s top 25 places to live a couple of weeks ago. So this blog post appears [...]